Final fields of the big races in South Africa are usually dissected after the Barrier Draw ceremony for a day or two and then everybody moves on from the sporadic grumblings that the final field panelists’ decisions invariably cause.

The Betway Summer Cup 2026 Barrier Draw ceremony was held today (Tuesday) at TAB Turffontein and was broadcast live.

There were a spate of scratchings before the final field panelists had to make their decisions, the difficulty of which can never be underestimated, but there were still some who questioned how Solar Sail and Legend Of Arthur could have got in ahead of some of the five eliminated horses, who were Isivivane, Field Marshal, Madison Valley, Busstopinhounslow and Indian Ocean.

The fight for two berths was between those seven if it is presumed the final log was steadfast and that the one-two in the Gr 3 Victory Moon Stakes, Parisian Walkway and Rule By Force, had selected themselves.

Legend Of Arthur was the winner of the 2025 Gr 1 SA Derby with Solar Sail a 0,45 length third.

Legend Of Arthur subsequently had eight consecutive unplaced runs, including finishing a 7.05 length eighth in the Summer Cup, 5 lengths behind Gr 3 Victory Moon Stakes winner The Ultimate King and 4,25 lengths behind Busstopinhounslow.

However, he was gelded this season and has started coming back into his own, culminating in a staying on 0,90 length third in the Gr 3 Victory Moon Stakes, in which he only faded right at the end. Sean Tarry is his trainer and the five-times Betway Summer Cup-winning trainer would likely have regarded that as the perfect preparation run into the big race. Legend Of Arthur will officially be 3,5kg under sufferance in the Summer Cup, but Tarry’s 2021 Summer Cup winner Flying Carpet was in fact 4kg under sufferance after coming into the big race off a Victory Moon fourth place finish.

Meanwhile, Solar Sail had been beaten 6,15 lengths in the Victory Moon Stakes last year by the runner up of that race, Field Marshal, and even if the latter was receiving 6kg from Solar Sail he still performed better than him at the weights.

However, Solar Sail found himself in the Summer Cup, with Field Marshal eliminated, only for Solar Sail to finish a tailed off last in the big race, while Field Marshal finished second in the Summer Cup consolation race in a quicker time than the Summer Cup winning time.

So, a year down the line Field Marshal’s connections, when looking through the list of horses still standing their ground, would have likely believed they would at least get in ahead of the 2025 SA Derby third-placed Solar Sail.

Since his Summer Consolation second Field Marshal has, among other races,  won the Listed Sledgehammer and had close fifths in the Gr 2 TAB Colorado King Stakes and Gr 3 Betgames Cup Trial and he was a 0,80 length fourth to Zeitz in the Listed Tote Stakes Darley Arabian over 1600m, carrying joint topweight.

It needn’t be stated how well that Zeitz form has stood up this season and Field Marshal is a proven stayer too having won the Listed Lonsdale Stirrup Cup  over 2400m last year.

Meanwhile, Solar Sail came out a month after his Summer Cup last place finish to win a Graduation Plate over 1600m, with an 80 rated horse finishing second and a well below par Parisian Walkway finishing fourth.

He was then laid off for ten months and was seen for the first time in ages only nine days ago. He ended up winning his comeback race though, even if it was in a four horse field in which one of the four  refused to race. One of the runners was the 2025 SA Derby runner up Wild Intent, who had also never franked that Gr 1 Classic’s form and he was beaten over seven lengths in this event.

The Progress Plate’s shorthead runner up was the 101-rated Porridge Boy, whom Solar Sail faced on 2kg terms worse than handicap terms off his 109 rating. So, the unfortunate part for Field Marshal was Solar Sail was duly raised to 112 and so is now two points higher in the merit ratings than him.

Whether it is a three horse field or not that is still recent handicap form and it was likely what got Solar Sail into the big race.

Field Marshal’s connections could counter argue by questioning how the 108-rated Legend Of Arthur got in ahead of the 110-rated Field Marshal, having not been able to run above his 108 mark in the Victory Moon?

However, that is where the panel’s discretion comes into it and they more than likely deemed Legend Of Arthur to be a Gr 1 winner, once rated 117, who was coming back into his own as opposed to a 110-rated horse who had never before performed above a 110.

Likewise, Solar Sail was once rated 115 and his comeback run suggests he can reach that level again.

The one saving grace of the 2025 SA Derby’s form was Olivia’s Way, who finished fourth in that race, and went on to continually perform to that level, including finishing second in last year’s Summer Cup which saw her raised from 112 to 116.

Isivivane’s connections might also have pointed out that he had, like Legend Of Arthur, had the perfect preparation. He not only won the Gr 3 WSB 1900, but he then finished an excellent fifth in the Gr 1 Hollywoodbets Durban July and his last run in the Gr 2 Allied Steelrode Onamission Charity Mile was an eyecatching effort, considering he was caught wide the whole way and was only beaten 3,65 lengths.

However, the panelists might also have viewed him as a 107-rated horse who had never risen above a 108 rating.

Isivivane should be a massive runner in the Consolation race.

Madison Valley and Busstopinhounslow, who have dropped to 111 and 108 merit ratings respectively from highs of 117 and 112, were the Summer Cup fourth-placed finishers of 2024 and 2025 respectively.

However, neither of them have finished in the frame in any of their races either this season or in the last part of last season, so it was hard to make a case for either of them.

Indian Ocean is rated only 105 and in his last nine starts has one second and eight unplaced runs.

There isn’t likely to be a great deal of fallout after this year’s Betway Summer Cup Barrier Draw ceremony with only five of the entries having to be eliminated.

However, a question that does arise from the final field process: can borderline cases in future simply book their places by winning or going close in ordinary races rather than tackling the big guns in races like the Gr 2 Charity Mile or other Graded features?